Business - Written by Mike Dover on Wednesday, June 24, 2009 8:36 - 5 Comments

Catcher in the Rye doesn’t translate for the Net Gen

Tags:

We’ve already seen a twitter version “Dad dead. Mom slut. Uncle sux. Talking emo 2 self: 2B? Not? Revenge? GF all wet. Her dad a rat” and Facebook version of Hamlet.

The New York Times posted an interesting article about another high school standard. The author attests that Gen Y readers don’t identify with Holden Caulfield. From the article:

The alienated teenager has lost much of his novelty, said Ariel Levenson, an English teacher at the Dalton School on Manhattan’s Upper East Side, Holden’s home turf. She added that even the students who liked the book tend to find the language — “phony,” “her hands were lousy with rocks,” the relentless “goddams” — grating and dated.

“Holden Caulfield is supposed to be this paradigmatic teenager we can all relate to, but we don’t really speak this way or talk about these things,” Ms. Levenson said, summarizing a typical response. At the public charter school where she used to teach, she said, “I had a lot of students comment, ‘I can’t really feel bad for this rich kid with a weekend free in New York City.’ ”

Julie Johnson, who taught Mr. Salinger’s novel over three decades at New Trier High School in Winnetka, Ill., cited similar reactions. “Holden’s passivity is especially galling and perplexing to many present-day students,” she wrote in an e-mail message. “In general, they do not have much sympathy for alienated antiheroes; they are more focused on distinguishing themselves in society as it is presently constituted than in trying to change it.”

In other news about Wikinomics and the Classics, this post brilliantly features customer reviews of products considered by all normal accounts to be spectacular. Some of my favourites:

The Godfather:

When’s an editor when you need one? This movie is so long that I played it on my TV, drove across the state, and when I came back, it was still playing. Since when is a movie this long? Movies are supposed to be 1:30-2:00 hours long. Plus this movie is as boring as a trip to the doctor’s. No good violence, no hot sex scenes, and furthermore, it stereotypes Italians. The only decent movie in this series is The Godfather III.

This is Spinal Tap:

If you’re going to make such an excellent documentary, why make it about about a band that nobody has ever heard of?

Getting similar behind-the-scenes footage on the Who, The Stones, or Genesis would have been a monumental achievment in documentary cinema.

But Spinal Pap?

The Princess Bride

I have no idea what this is. This can’t be a movie because movies are supposed to be good. The story is assanine and unbelievable. The title makes no sense. What exactly is a princess bride who is named after a buttercup. I was made to watch this movie in school and it was torture. Thank you.

Moby Dick

This book is HORRIBLE! Classic, my eye! I would love to know what’s so great about this book. I have seen better writing in a Hallmark card! Boring! Give me a good ole copy of Elvis and Me! A true story that really tugs at your heart strings! I sleep with that one under my pillow! Keep Moby Dick away from my bed!



5 Comments

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Louise McGregor
Jun 24, 2009 16:26

I’m not surprised, I hated Catcher in the Rye when I read it (under duress) 25 years ago.

All I can say is I’m glad there’s no “Part 2″.

Mike Dover
Jun 24, 2009 19:55

Louise…ah, but there is.

Salinger didn’t write it though.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2009/jun/02/jd-salinger-legal-action-against-sequel-author

MaryFran Lynch
Jun 25, 2009 14:33

I’m very surprised. My daughter is 22 and read Catcher in the Rye in high school. She loved the book so much she read it multiple times and it was one of the few paperbacks she packed to take with her to college. We never really talked about it, I just assumed she’d been drawn to it as I had as a teenager.

Catcher in the Rye ve Net Jenerasyonu | 3G Cep Telefonları
Jun 25, 2009 19:21

[...] sitesinde guzel bir yazi. Yazar Mike Dover’a gore yeni nesil “eskilerin klasikleri” Catcher in the Rye, [...]

Adam Clarke
Jul 9, 2009 12:48

Wow! Interesting subject with some excellent perspective examples.

A main point in all of this is that the NetGen are progressing full-flow into working environments and shifting attitudes. Old school organisations are forced to keep up with innovations coming from the youth who know no boundaries.

In this, I think that there is a huge class of highschool students (think back to our schooling days) who appreciate literature and the time for which the piece was written. Can we truly relate to the characters of Dickens et al – probably not, but we get the human undertones. Similar is true of Chaucer, even the Bible. More often than not, books studied are about the human condition and it’s moral mortality. This will long prevail.

This post does raise some interesting points though. It hints more at a youthful society that questions ‘WHY’ as opposed to a ‘pack-minded’ youth of previous times perhaps? In this model comparison, it is invariably the ‘questioners’ who provide true innovation to industries and society as a whole. With so many NetGens questioning and ‘doing their own thing’ – the landscape is full of excitement with a slight concern that new commerce models can’t keep up.

I would love to get the view from NetGen about Orwells ‘1984′. Now that would be interesting. On a scale, at the time the readership were shocked that such a society could exist (with the undertone that it already did behind closed doors), a generation up kind of accepted it with a hint of paranoia. Surely NetGen would be indifferent about the prospect?!

Great post.

Leave a Reply

Comment

Browse Content

Business - Mar 11, 2010 8:56 - 0 Comments

Will You Use Target’s Mobile Coupons?

More In Business


Entertainment - Mar 9, 2010 16:58 - 3 Comments

Lessons in collaboration from B.B. King’s

More In Entertainment


Government, Society - Mar 5, 2010 6:01 - 2 Comments

A decade of frustration ahead?

More In Society