Business - Written by Jeff DeChambeau on Thursday, July 10, 2008 12:01 - 9 Comments

Jeff DeChambeau
Sneak Peak at the Absolutely Terrible Facebook Redesign!

A friend of mine informed me that you can check out the new facebook profile layout early (but you need to install the developer application to see it) — it goes live on the 17th of this month. In case you don’t want to install the application to check it out for yourself, here’s a screenshot:

I would actually go so far as to say that the screenshot and cropping job that I did actually makes it look a lot better than it does in your browser. If you don’t check it out now, you’ll see it when it goes live in a couple of weeks. My concerns are chiefly that things aren’t where you’d expect that they are, and wherever you do find them, they’re ugly.

The issue is that this new design doesn’t agree with existing user habits, and therefore gets in the way of simply using the platform. There’s quote that says that technology is anything that doesn’t quite work yet, it seems that the current version of facebook simply worked in so many ways that it ceased to be technological and was just useful. My concern is that this new layout will push the platform back into the domain of technology for its users, resulting in much frustration and many loud complaints.



9 Comments

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Kyle Maxwell
Jul 10, 2008 12:16

I’m not sure; I just joined Facebook two weeks ago and the UI seems opaque at best. Streamlining things so they’re in more logical places and easier to find would be helpful.

Doug Cornelius
Jul 10, 2008 13:50

Jeff –

It is different, but I do not that it is terrible. The current UI is a mess. This new, streamlined view organizes things better.

But I am merely a casual user of Facebook.

I found having everything on one Facebook page to be too much. Pages took long to load and information was in different places. The new design chops things up into more accessible chunks.

Jeff DeChambeau
Jul 10, 2008 17:37

Hey Doug,

I don’t agree that the current UI is a mess, but I’ve become something of a heavy user, so much in the same way that I knew how to get around Word (before the ribbon), things just worked for me. I think I grant that the UI is a mess, with the caveat that it’s my mess, or, rather, a mess that I’ve built up a lot of habits around. If the layout really is usable in some way that I don’t currently see, I still get the feeling that I’m not going to enjoy learning something new.

Take the QWERTY keyboard layout, for example, it’s specifically designed to be as inconvenient as possible, but it’s become the standard, and not many people are switching over DVORAK. Given that I don’t want to make a “well it’s a fact of life” argument, I’m still really not a fan of the new design on aesthetic grounds.

Brittany Creamer
Jul 10, 2008 17:59

Noooo!!!! As an avid Facebook user, I really hate when Facebook changes things up and moves things around. At least for someone who visits the site daily, the UI is quite intuitive and easy to maneuver and major changes are not welcome. Of course, I’m no UI expert, but I am a Facebook expert. I’m not looking forward to have to tab through someone’s info rather than have it plainly visible. I see this as a way for Facebook to increase click-throughs and page visits in an effort to generate more ad revenue. Rant over.

Thusenth
Jul 10, 2008 20:38

Facebook’s current design wasn’t built for the loads of Facebook applications that now litter most pages. Unfortunately for developers, the app boxes are now on a separate page.

The most active content on Facebook is the wall, and they’ve integrated it with the newsfeed, which then connects you to other updated content.

The new design is better focused, and will load much faster without having to pull application content.

Jeff DeChambeau
Jul 10, 2008 21:03

Thusenth: Yeah, this does shunt applications away (which the devs might not appreciate, though I certainly will), but when was the last time you actually read someone elses wall as opposed to just their minifeed?

Denis Hancock
Jul 15, 2008 11:51

I continue to be intrigued by what the cat said that deemed it worthy of being fuzzed out. :)

Wikinomics » Blog Archive » Facebook plans for Web domination
Jul 25, 2008 10:40

[...] 10:40am If you logged onto Facebook this morning, you may have noticed the new interface that we wrote about a couple of weeks ago. What’s really exciting though, is what’s going on behind the [...]

Jeremy Smith
Sep 13, 2008 20:02

There are a few arguments for, but many against the new layout. As one who has used both now (and given the new a fair chance), I can easily state that the new layout is far less logical. Perhaps having so much of ones personal information displayed on the one page didn’t jive with some users tastes, but I can assure you it was straight forward and practical. This modification is purely aimed at adverstisers wellbeing. I’ve not yet met anyone that prefers the new layout. Based solely on the numbers of complaints circulating Google, one would think that management would sit up and take note. Not so. Shame on you Facebook.

Leave a Reply

Comment

Browse Content

Business - Mar 19, 2010 16:57 - 0 Comments

Addressing the social media ‘support gap’

More In Business


Entertainment - Mar 9, 2010 16:58 - 3 Comments

Lessons in collaboration from B.B. King’s

More In Entertainment


Society - Mar 17, 2010 9:45 - 0 Comments

On unintended consequences

More In Society