Entertainment - Written by Naumi Haque on Friday, July 4, 2008 9:05 - 8 Comments

Naumi Haque
George A. Romero Unrealistic About Zombie Impact on Web 2.0

I just watched George A. Romero’s Diary of the Dead last weekend. For those who haven’t seen it, it’s your typical zombie apocalypse movie – the reanimated dead wreck havoc, attempting to eat the living; mass hysteria ensues; a small band of survivors kill zombies in gruesome ways until they realize the inevitability of their fate. Now, for the non-zombie fans, the interesting thing about this particular movie is the sub-plot that tells of the group of film students’ need to document the end-of-days (kind of similar to the movie Cloverfield). Now, I’m not one to argue the “facts” in a film about zombies, but here’s where it gets a little whacky. The movie postulates that if there was a zombie apocalypse, the fall of big media would result in bloggers taking over, leading to infinite voices and more spin:

“The mainstream had vanished with all its power and money. Now it was just us, bloggers, hackers, kids. The more voices there are, the more spin there is. The truth becomes that much harder to find. In the end, it’s just noise.”

Clearly, George did not read Wikinomics. It’s true that big media would fall with studios being overrun by the living dead, and that bloggers and citizen journalist would carry on. But, all accounts we’ve seen of bloggers and citizen journalists suggest that the more eyes you have on a story and the more voices you have reporting, the less spin there is. In fact, the truth is usually obfuscated by big media, not the other way around. Moreover, in times of crisis, we’ve seen that small groups of individuals working together online have been extremely affective at mobilizing aid and sharing information – just think of the Katrina People Finder Project and other related initiatives.


The second question raised in the Romero movie is whether or not Web communication would go down in a time of war. When the band of survivors’ Web feed dies part way through the movie, one of the characters notes:

“The f#*#@!% service is going down… there’s nothing… how could there be nothing. The relay towers are out.”

Seems a bit simplistic. I mean, what about cell phone networks, satellite communications, and personal LANs? Maybe I’m wrong, but would think that the Internet would carry on even with limited human involvement. Maybe power would be first to fail, leading to other outages? Hmm… Note to self: In case of zombie war, be sure to charge cell phone and laptop…



8 Comments

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Andrew
Jul 4, 2008 11:15

Wow, great blog post. It made me both think and reminded me that I still had to see Diary of the Dead.

Sam Toman
Jul 4, 2008 11:53

I agree totally. I’m a huge Romero fan, and willing to give him the benefit of every doubt. But in this case it’s just too thin.

For anyone looking for a much more sophisticated take on the role the web would take in a pandemic type situation I would suggest World War Z by Max Brooks (son of Mel).

In one chapter of this “oral history of the Zombie War” a young Japanese Okatu tells his story of sharing and distributing information with a wide group of people around the world.

It’s been a while since I read the book, but it seemed fairly plausible… with the exception of a still-functioning power grid amidst mass panic.

Perhaps Mr. Haque has read this book and can offer his thoughts?

Eric Campbell
Jul 4, 2008 13:18

ha ha. Love this post. I think your analysis is spot on.

Gabriele Paolacci
Jul 4, 2008 14:03

it was AMAZING as a Romero’s zombies addicted to find such a post!

Craig Williamson
Jul 6, 2008 17:34

There’s a book called “The World Without Us” by science writer, Alan Weisman. He details what would likely happen to all our collective “stuff” if we disappeared instantaneously. It seems that power plants have numerous safety systems which shut down pretty quickly without an operator. Without power more things than you care to imagine would be in trouble. Picture subway tunnels filling with water (no power, no water pumps).

I haven’t read the book so I don’t know how the web could be affected but I think communication would be pretty spotty in the event of a severe pandemic or war. Oddly I think I’d rather take the zombie war, they’ve never struck me as overly strategic and so they might hit the mall before the power plants buying us a little time.

Either way it would be exciting times, pigeons would reign supreme yet again.

Naumi Haque
Jul 7, 2008 19:37

As a matter of fact, I’m reading World War Z right now, unfortunately I haven’t reached the part about how well the Internet fares, but I’ll post an update when I do. Excellent book for those who haven’t read it. It ventures into the social, political, economic, and military implications of an apocalyptic event – in this case zombies – but probably equally relevant for any other mass global catastrophe. Seems to be pretty well researched and thought out.

Craig, thanks for the heads up on The World Without Us – I’ve added it to my Amazon list and plan on checking it out.

Wyatt
Sep 10, 2008 1:22

I just watched the scene you were quoting and had to see if anyone was talking about the quote. I am glad to see that you are.

That being said, I took it to mean the opposite given the context of the quote. She is talking about how the media obfuscates the facts and that is why it is important for them to document the truth and broadcast it on myspace. Maybe I am reading into it, but it sounded more like a criticism of mainstream media creating spin (like the deceitful editing of the initial scene).

Wikinomics» Blog Archive » Wikinomics lessons from Zombie attacks
Apr 1, 2009 12:21

[...] in the book gave me a new insight into wikinomics (see other wikinomics zombie mentions here and here). [if you plan to read the book, stop here, minor spoiler [...]

Leave a Reply

Comment

Browse Content

Business - Mar 19, 2010 16:57 - 0 Comments

Addressing the social media ‘support gap’

More In Business


Entertainment - Mar 9, 2010 16:58 - 3 Comments

Lessons in collaboration from B.B. King’s

More In Entertainment


Society - Mar 17, 2010 9:45 - 0 Comments

On unintended consequences

More In Society