Business - Written by Deepak Ramachandran on Wednesday, June 4, 2008 11:33 - 2 Comments
Media Oligopolies (or, why I love BitTorrent)
This Saturday, I’m going with my wife Alex to see Leonard Cohen in concert. We’re really looking forward to it!
But I’ve got to say, there’s a reason why we do so few of these live events these days. It’s not just the $200 tickets — @#&#! the Rolling Stones for setting a new standard in crazy live-event prices! (>smile< — Really, they deserve it.) It’s the pain in the ass of dealing with all these media oligopolies just to have a little fun. Anytime you want to show up to something in-person, it’s a nightmare of logistics. Wanna watch at home, at your leisure, when and where you like? That’s easy, thanks to BitTorrent.
Why would anyone go to a live event again?
I know it’s old news, but it still rankles. Almost every media business has been built on a natural oligopoly model, which is why we have 1 TicketMaster, 4 TV networks, 1 local cable option, and 1 or 2 major theatre chains (in disguise, by the way, under multiple seemingly competitive brands). The internet, of course, has cleared the way for digital delivery of most media content — which is why we can get it easier, faster, simpler there (let alone free).
The media companies are like the pharmaceuticals. They claim they need high prices to pay the talent (in pharma, the R&D). But in fact, they pay more in sales and marketing costs than to talent! Give us an optional “pay what you believe is right” button, and many of us will take that over the current obsolete models every time.
What part of the TicketMaster experience is fun? Getting kicked off the website every 10 seconds? Logging in at the precise time the tickets go on sale, just to find all the tickets are sold out? Paying the insane “transaction charges” on top of the already-crazy ticket price?
(The only good news here is that the performers are finally getting their fair share of the proceeds. Years ago, I saw Miles Davis, Oscar Peterson, Sarah Vaughan and Dizzy Gillespie — all just before they died. Then, I saw Ella Fitzgerald, seemingly just *after* she died! She was struggling on stage, telling the same two jokes in alternation literally between every song. Why did she need to tour in her 80s? Because she never got the money she deserved in the first place. The same can’t be said of Leonard Cohen, whose current tour is at least in part an attempt to make back the money he lost by trusting an unqualified “financial advisor”.)
Of course, the live show is the point — and it’s often great. But at some point, the pain of getting there outstrips the fun of being there.
This nutty situation doesn’t just apply to live music. We tried to see a movie the other day, and had the same experience. We had bought tickets using Air Miles (what else are they good for? Search me), but of course it turned out they weren’t valid for a Saturday night show (read the fine print). Then, of course, there’s the crazy prices for popcorn and drinks. And then 10 minutes of trailers and commercials. Why do I have to sit through commercials after *paying* for my show?
Even TV is a pain. Our latest craze at home is *Battlestar Galactica*, which we watch by downloading the old episodes. 41 minutes per episode, and they expect us to sit through another 20 minutes of distractions and commercials?!
The only thing missing on BitTorrent is the ability to pay the people who made the content. I’d love a “pay what you think this is worth” button. For those who are wondering, I’m not a fan of just buying the stuff on iTunes, only to find it works only once, or I can’t build it into my home videos for my friends….
Maybe one day, we’ll be able to send people money over a DNS protocol, much as we can currently find any website. In the meantime, I know this rant is old news, but the idiocy of our media business models irritates me still.
2 Comments
Well, you and Mark Cuban certainly have different perspectives!!
http://www.blogmaverick.com/2008/06/04/why-tiered-broadband-is-a-wonderful-thing-and-asivs/
Leave a Reply
Browse Content
- Car 2.0 - How a community builds a car
- The iPhone, growing up digital, and my daughter's education
- The dangers of GeoTweeting: PleaseRobMe.com
- Playbor: When work and fun coincide
- Lessons in collaboration from B.B. King’s
- A decade of frustration ahead?
- Games, user experience, and retroactive Continuity--All enabled by platforms
- Survey: How prepared is the enterprise to lead in the age of unbounded data?
- When you ask customers to dance, let them lead
- Real world examples for collaboration ROI
- Will You Use Target’s Mobile Coupons?
- Lessons in collaboration from B.B. King’s
- Games, user experience, and retroactive Continuity–All enabled by platforms
- Survey: How prepared is the enterprise to lead in the age of unbounded data?
- A decade of frustration ahead?
- The iPhone, growing up digital, and my daughter’s education
- Real world examples for collaboration ROI
- Playbor: When work and fun coincide
- Security, security, security…
- When you ask customers to dance, let them lead
- Car 2.0 – How a community builds a car
- Not everybody will have read Malthus. And the the title heading of this post app...
- Given the numbers not connected properly, there's continuous digital divide....
- Quite possibly....
- Due to global financial crisis companies and individuals are affected. Many work...
- Good post Naumi,
I like how you relate the jazz band performance to customer ...
- Hi Marilyn,
Thanks for the quote! I agree that some of the most interesting...
- Hi Friends H r u? I hope all is well...This is very true! Most gamers I know hav...
- Wonderful rich thought provoking analogies and a re quote of a favourite quote f...
Business - Mar 11, 2010 8:56 - 0 Comments
Will You Use Target’s Mobile Coupons?
More In Business
- Games, user experience, and retroactive Continuity–All enabled by platforms
- Survey: How prepared is the enterprise to lead in the age of unbounded data?
- Real world examples for collaboration ROI
- When you ask customers to dance, let them lead
- Car 2.0 – How a community builds a car
Entertainment - Mar 9, 2010 16:58 - 3 Comments
Lessons in collaboration from B.B. King’s
More In Entertainment
- CL!CK – LEGO’s fun social product development platform
- Peer Pressure 2.0: Farmville
- Online gaming more than just fun
- The NFL – The most protective league, attempting to control the uncontrollable
- The rise of computational photography and the birth of camera 2.0
Government, Society - Mar 5, 2010 6:01 - 2 Comments
A decade of frustration ahead?
More In Society
- The iPhone, growing up digital, and my daughter’s education
- Playbor: When work and fun coincide
- Security, security, security…
- The dangers of GeoTweeting: PleaseRobMe.com
- Self-destructing data: The return of Internet privacy


We made an amazing discovery in 2007 — that you can invite amazing performers to your house, and they will COME.
House concerts have been an ‘under-the-radar’ sort of thing for years, if not decades.
But if you’re tired of the logistics and limitations of traditional live music venues (which one is Celine? Can I borrow your binoculars? Why is everyone on their cell phone?), house concerts are an amazing, intimate, profound experience of music.
There’s even an attempt to build house-concert infrastructure without losing that intimacy — http://homeroutes.ca/