Business - Written by Dan Herman on Monday, November 26, 2007 11:44 - 9 Comments
All bugs are shallow…
Years ago in his fantastic Linux related essay, The Cathedral and the Bazaar, Eric Raymond wrote “given enough eyeballs, all bugs are shallow.”
Today this applies way beyond software, and increasingly in the field of government and governance. We’ve talked several times about how citizen blogs, citizen journalism, and the massive networks, both formal and informal, of concerned global citizens are creating a new paradigm within which governments must operate.
So whether it’s the use of YouTube (while under house arrest) or the blogosphere to help bring light to the situation in Pakistan, or the use of mobiles and the Net to help local councils literally fix themselves up, the public is increasingly able to enact greater scrutiny on the activities of government.
A great example is the site ManyEyes. Sponsored by IBM, the site takes publicly available data and turns it into some pretty interesting visualizations. Be it related to environmental, social or political issues, the site allows users (i.e. you and me) to graph data and subsequently draw the appropriate links to whatever it is we’re trying to prove. For example, one might look at a comparison of U.S. state emission rates and draw the conclusion that cows, not cars, are the real evil behind global warming. Evidently, such visualizations need some dialogue to become truly useable but nonetheless they create a tremendous window for engagement in policy. And combined with a plethora of similar sites and mashups such as those created by Sunlight labs, each of us has the tools to become modern-day Bob Woodwards or Carl Bernsteins….
9 Comments
Naumi Haque
DH
One step at a time Naumi, one step at a time. It took nearly 5 years for Nixon to fall after Watergate came to light.
Smart Mobs » Blog Archive » All bugs are shallow . . .
[...] folks at the WIKINOMICS blog have a post titled “All bugs are shallow . . . ” They explain: Years ago in his fantastic Linux related essay, The Cathedral and the Bazaar, Eric [...]
I should say that availability of a medium by which the public is “increasingly able to enact greater scrutiny on the activities of government” (Herman 2007) is an important consideration since access to a meaningful communication is essential before a something can be uploaded and consequently downloaded within a “political platform”. I would argue that technology has both a colonization and peripheralization imperative – it affects tremendously those who have advantage while excludes in the process the already voiceless majority. So who has the advantage to peek into that “window of engagement” (Herman 2007)? And who are the ones creating that new paradigm? ‘We’ and ‘us’ are dangerous pronouns, because while they are normally believed to be inclusive, they always refer to that group of people who gather together in the same hall.
DH
Miko – definitely! One of the biggest thrusts of our Gov 2.0 research is on the question of who is being engaged/who is participating. Is it simply those who are already part of the process? Those who self-select in as participants? Or do these new mediums actually create an incentive, and means, of broader participation? And, ultimately, does it matter? How does it impact the democratic process? A very fascinating area of investigation.
We interviewed the UK CIO, John Suffolk, a few weeks backm and he noted that in order to make this a truly holistic medium you first had to address the digital divide, thus enabling the voiceless majority to join the discussion. Tall order.
These are very interesting questions Dan. I can now see how the Chamber’s school at IDS has greatly evolved with the advent of technology. Fullspeed! Will findings be made available at no cost? Well, that’s again another access question, and again from the perspective of the periphery. Conversely, how far can the findings go? Again, another access question; which gives me the idea that the “autocrat” is better positioned to install research findings into action, no matter how loud Manhattan Transfer would sing “Park Chung Hee was a wanted man…”
There are two groups; those that ‘get it’ and those that do not. Efficiency is the name of the game in business and those who cling to structure-the tangible- have ‘insecurity’ written all over their faces. I have begun to give the book “Wikinomics” to those who yearn to work smarter and quicker.
Wikinomics » Blog Archive » Forget the file, bake a cellphone into my cake.
[...] of countries are now more open to the speculation of the world community. Earlier, Dan wrote a post on the role of citizen journalism in transforming government. In it, he [...]
Wikinomics » Blog Archive » A picture made of 1000 words
[...] 06:54pm We’ve blogged before about visualization tools like ManyEyes and Swivel (here, here, and here), but I thought I’d reiterate the point of how powerful and readily available these [...]
Leave a Reply
Browse Content
- The Empire strikes a light
- Questioning the idea that 'the customer is now in control'
- You don't have to engage in conversations to succeed on Twitter
- The importance of being competent
- Two cool maps
- You don’t have to engage in conversations to succeed on Twitter
- A visual model showing the value of open data
- Better parking through technology
- A view of self through a digital mirror
- Questioning the idea that ‘the customer is now in control’
- The Empire strikes a light
- Balance: customer receptivity vs. customer revulsion
- Want to see the future? Look to the games
- Ride and surf
- Trapster will top 8 M users in 2 weeks. How do they make money?...
- Agree with your post. I think this is based on misunderstanding and miseducation...
- Naumi,
I liked the development of the intersection between numbers of projects...
- Totally agree there's not just one way to use Twitter, and as an example, I have...
- The fastest country is South Korea.
Im not able to bolive this...
- Oops, left out a bit: "and trying to keep your hypocrisy private is harder than ...
- Thanks for the comment, John.
I wrote a report at the end of 2009 called Succes...
- It’s easier to work towards your own interests than working together as a grou...
Business - Aug 31, 2010 15:47 - 0 Comments
The importance of being competent
More In Business
- Two cool maps
- You don’t have to engage in conversations to succeed on Twitter
- A view of self through a digital mirror
- Questioning the idea that ‘the customer is now in control’
- This never gets old: Social media can cost you your job
Entertainment - Aug 3, 2010 13:14 - 0 Comments
Want to see the future? Look to the games
More In Entertainment
- Lessons in collaboration from B.B. King’s
- CL!CK – LEGO’s fun social product development platform
- Peer Pressure 2.0: Farmville
- Online gaming more than just fun
- The NFL – The most protective league, attempting to control the uncontrollable
Society - Aug 6, 2010 8:19 - 4 Comments
The Empire strikes a light
More In Society
- Balance: customer receptivity vs. customer revulsion
- The Net Gen: Too plugged-in for parenting?
- Are you addicted to social media?
- The privacy discussion we need to have
- “The Data-Driven Life”: Who’s not interested in discovery?



The assumption of course is that illuminating the bugs will actually lead to them being resolved. Unfortunately political “bugs” seem to take a long time to fix.